Coca-Cola Life was Discontinued

WHY COCA-COLA LIFE WAS DISCONTINUED & FAILED

© History Oasis
"Even in the vast ocean of commerce, the best-intended ships can miss the harbor of success if they fail to catch the winds of consumer desire."

—Lee Iacocca

Amidst the mid-2010s, the world witnessed a burgeoning awareness around health, sustainability, and organic consumption.

This global shift led Coca-Cola to introduce 'Life', aiming to tap into the zeitgeist of natural and low-calorie products.

However, amidst rapid changes in consumer preferences and the rising popularity of other no-sugar drinks, Coca-Cola Life was discontinued in 2017.

A SHORT HISTORY OF COCA-COLA LIFE

Coca-Cola Life launch
Source: The Coca-Cola Company

2014 stands out as a significant year for the Coca-Cola Company.

The unveiling of 'Life' represented more than just another product—it was the company's earnest attempt to align with the burgeoning health-conscious movement of the times.

Embracing a revolutionary formula, 'Life' sought to strike a delicate balance between the iconic Coca-Cola flavor and the rising demand for more natural, health-centric beverages.

The incorporation of cane sugar, with its age-old appeal, coupled with stevia leaf extract, a sweetener long praised in indigenous cultures for its natural origins, showcased a bold experimentation in taste and health.

As the product made its debut in diverse markets ranging from the lush landscapes of Costa Rica to the vast expanses of Australia, it became evident that Coca-Cola was making a concerted effort to gauge global reception. Such a widespread initial launch was indicative of the company's confidence in the product's universal appeal.

However, as the product journeyed further to the bustling streets of the U.S., the serene countrysides of Canada, and the historically rich lanes of the U.K., a pattern emerged.

Despite its global footprint, 'Life' never achieved the ubiquitous presence of its siblings in the Coca-Cola family. It remained an intriguing chapter—a symbol of the company's adaptability to changing times—based on the challenges of introducing nuanced flavors in an ever-evolving global palate.

Symbolism in Branding

The verdant shade adorning the logo of Coca-Cola Life was emblematic of a broader cultural narrative unfolding in the early 21st century.

This deliberate chromatic decision was a nod to the surging global sentiment favoring environmental consciousness and a move towards organic consumption.

When Coca-Cola Life emerged on the American scene, it carried the weight of being the brand's pioneering venture in nearly ten years. Historically, such intervals between product introductions have been precursors to heightened anticipation and scrutiny.

CONSUMER CONFUSION

Coca-Cola Life Ad with a girl looking at the camera
Source: The Coca-Cola Company

The quagmire Coca-Cola Life found itself in wasn't unique but mirrored challenges faced by several other products in various epochs.

Was it, as many wondered, a salubrious iteration of the cherished Coca-Cola, or was it merely the familiar drink with subdued sugar levels?

This conundrum was reminiscent of the debacle faced by New Coke in the 1980s. Similarly, the automobile industry saw the Edsel by Ford in the late 1950s, which suffered from a confused market position—was it a luxury car or a budget-friendly model for the masses?

Further parallels can be drawn with the branding struggles of Crystal Pepsi in the early 1990s. Its clear coloration left consumers befuddled: Was it a lemon-lime soda or an uncolored cola?

The murkiness in brand messaging hindered market adoption.

SOME PEOPLE DIDN’T LIKE THE TASTE

Coca-Cola Life Ad with the bottle in the grass
Source: The Coca-Cola Company

When Coca-Cola Life made its debut, it promised a novel taste, an amalgamation of the familiar with the fresh.

However, the reception was polarized.

To some palates, the drink was cloyingly sweet, a far cry from the crispness they expected.

Others, in stark contrast, felt the concoction lacked character, finding it insipid and lackluster.

Historical parallels can be drawn to the launch of New Coke in 1985, where an altered formula led to public outcry and longing for the original taste. Similarly, the world of wine has witnessed numerous vintages that, despite their pedigree, failed to achieve universal adulation due to their divisive flavor profiles.

Coca-Cola Life's history underscores a timeless truth in the world of beverages: while innovation is commendable, achieving a balance that pleases the global palate is a daunting task.

THE MARKETING DIDN’T RESONATE

A Coca-Cola Life Ad in France
Source: The Coca-Cola Company

Coca-Cola has been synonymous with iconic advertising campaigns, weaving its way into the very cultural fabric of societies. Its advertisements, ranging from the annual heartwarming Christmas trucks to the famous "I'd Like to Buy the World a Coke" campaign, have resonated deeply with generations.

However, when it came to championing 'Life', the narrative took an unexpected turn.

The promotional material for 'Life' leaned heavily on its green branding, aiming to evoke feelings of naturalness and environmental consciousness. Vignettes of families enjoying nature, serene outdoor settings, and close-ups of the distinct green-labeled bottle were commonplace.

The messaging strived to emphasize its healthier credentials and natural sweetening.

But amidst these visual presentations, the true essence of the beverage was lost. The campaign seemed to lack the emotional punch and universal appeal that had been the hallmark of Coca-Cola's previous ads.

Where previous campaigns celebrated moments of joy, unity, and global togetherness, 'Life's advertisements were somewhat muted, failing to resonate deeply with its intended audience.

COCA-COLA LIFE WAS DISCONTINUED & REPLACED BY COKE ZERO

A Coca-Cola Zero Sugar ad with a woman sipping the drink
Source: The Coca-Cola Company

As Coca-Cola Life witnessed its sun setting, shadows cast by the twilight of its tenure were pierced by the nascent glow of Coca-Cola Zero Sugar.

By June 2017, the curtains were drawn on Coca-Cola Life.

The declining sales metrics, combined with shifting company priorities, sealed its fate.

However, this termination wasn't without its share of lamentations, especially from a niche yet devoted consumer base that had developed a fondness for the drink.

Drawing lessons from the Life endeavor, Coca-Cola Zero Sugar was launched with clearer branding and sharper messaging, positioning itself as the answer for those seeking the classic Coca-Cola flavor without the calorific guilt.

Precedents have shown that when a company introduces multiple products in close succession, they run the risk of internal competition. A prime example is the rivalry of early 20th-century automobile variants within companies leading to the prioritization of one model over another.

With the ascendancy of Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, 'Life', already grappling with identity and taste issues, found itself further overshadowed.

The market, ever fickle and driven by trends, gravitated towards the clear promise of Zero Sugar. As the annals of beverage history now reflect, while 'Life' was a bold experiment in a shifting market, its flame was dimmed by the brighter, more resonant star that was Coca-Cola Zero Sugar.

Collection

Next