The Unknown History of Diet Pepsi

THE UNKNOWN HISTORY OF DIET PEPSI

© History Oasis

Arriving amidst 1960s crazes for skinny bodies and calorie-counting, pioneering diet soda Diet Pepsi soon found itself immersed in Assassinations, Vietnam War protests, and Civil Rights marches defining that turbulent age.

While clashing with rival Coca-Cola in Cola Wars spanning the Watergate scandal and Reagan Revolution, Diet Pepsi navigated sweetener controversies recast by environmentalism’s rise and emerging health consciousness.

Through dynamic decades witnessing everything from celebrity aerobics videos to the Dot-com bubble and Clinton impeachment, the landmark low-calorie pop maintained fizzy sales, adapting its formula and star-studded marketing to shifting consumer tastes around Atkins and Adkins alike.

DIET PEPSI WAS ORIGINALLY TEST MARKETED UNDER THE NAME PATIO DIET COLA

vintage Patio Diet Cola ad
Source: PepsiCo

In the early 1960s, as awareness grew concerning the health impacts of high sugar intake, PepsiCo set its sights on developing a lower calorie cola option to appeal to newly diet-conscious consumers.

Their product developers formulated a diet cola recipe which would come to be known as “Patio Diet Cola.”

This proto-diet Pepsi was test released in select markets in 1963, the first such low calorie soda produced by a major American company.

Though initially dubbed “Patio,” PepsiCo landed on the name “Diet Pepsi” for its national unveiling the following year.

Backed by PepsiCo’s formidable distribution capabilities, Diet Pepsi was launched countrywide in 1964, breaking ground as the very first mass-distributed diet soda pop in the modern United States.

Seeking to re-energize Cola Wars in the age of healthy lifestyles, PepsiCo had introduced an innovative product which changed the arc of diet beverage history.

DIET PEPSI HAS HAD MANY CONTROVERSIES OVER ITS ARTIFICIAL SWEETENERS

old school Diet Pepsi ad
Source: PepsiCo

When first formulated in the early 1960s, Diet Pepsi derived its sugarless sweetness from the artificial sweetener saccharin, the choice ingredient of diet soda creators at the time.

However, in the 1970s, controversy erupted as animal studies linked saccharin with bladder cancer, sparking a public panic.

Though later deemed safe for human consumption, the episode shook confidence in early diet soda sweeteners.

Seeking to dissociate from embattled saccharin, Diet Pepsi and other major brands shifted sweeteners in 1983, adopting the next-generation option aspartame.

However, aspartame soon courted its own controversy after allegations of brain tumor risks, tarnishing its public safety perception.

Still reeling from ongoing aspartame skepticism in 2012, parent company PepsiCo attempted transitioning Diet Pepsi to the sweetener sucralose to quell health fears.

But the taste divergence provoked an immediate backlash from devoted brand loyalists.

Through recurrent controversies surrounding its sweetening agents, Diet Pepsi learned reformulating deeply-rooted products risks the ire of vocal consumer advocates, even given changing health recommendations over time.

DIET PEPSI COMPETED PRIMARILY WITH TAB

vintage Tab ad
Source: The Coca-Cola Company

Hitting the market in 1964 as the first mass-distributed diet soda in America, upstart Diet Pepsi initially competed for sales predominantly against The Coca-Cola Corporation’s first sugar-free offering, Tab Cola.

Billed the calorie-free Coke, Tab had launched just three years prior, rapidly becoming diet soda’s leading brand.

Through nearly two decades from the mid 1960s onward, Tab remained the prime rival squaring off on supermarket shelves against newcomer Diet Pepsi in the burgeoning diet pop segment.

However, competition in the category was upended in 1982 with Coca-Cola’s launch of Diet Coke, its boldest bid yet to dominate the thriving niche demand for low and no calorie sparkling beverages.

Reformulated to closely mimic the iconic Coke flavor profile, all-new Diet Coke proved an overnight sensation upon debut, usurping Tab as America’s top selling sugar-free fizzy drink.

Practically overnight, Diet Pepsi had itself a new archnemesis—Diet Coke and Pepsi’s famous "Cola Wars" extended now to the calorie-conscious.

IN 2010, IT A 5.3 PERCENT SHARE SOFT DRINK SALES

Modern Diet Pepsi ad
Source: PepsiCo

By the dawn of the 2010s, Diet Pepsi had cemented itself as a staple of the soft drink scene, though its supremacy had somewhat waned from earlier heydays.

According to industry sales data, the diet cola commanded 5.3 percent of the entire American carbonated beverage market that year.

A respectable figure in isolation, but Diet Pepsi found itself outpaced by rival Coca-Cola brands within the diet soda wars.

As the 7th best selling soft drink overall on US shelves in 2010, it trailed not only surging category leader Diet Coke, but also the #4 placed Coke Zero products.

Once a trailblazer as the first-ever diet soda distributed nationally in the 1960s, Diet Pepsi was lately struggling to keep pace with diversifying consumer preferences for healthier or more natural beverage options entering the marketplace.

While still a power player in the industry, Diet Pepsi’s footing had relatively slipped.

MICHAEL J. FOX, RAY CHARLES, & CINDY CRAWFORD HAVE BEEN FEATURED IN ADS

Source: PepsiCola

Seeking an extra dash of star power to promote its sugar-free cola to status-conscious consumers, Diet Pepsi forged creative partnerships with contemporary celebrities at the height of their fame spanning decades.

In the late 1980s, Diet Pepsi cast blockbuster Back to the Future star Michael J. Fox in a memorable sci-fi inspired campaign playing alongside his robot clone.

The 1990s then saw music legend Ray Charles as Diet Pepsi’s premier pitchman, crooning “You Got the Right One Baby” in reference to the drink’s taste.

Later, supermodel Cindy Crawford, renown international symbol for beauty in that era, signed on as an ongoing Diet Pepsi spokesperson across print and television advertisements through the early 2000s.

By aligning Diet Pepsi with household names of their times, marketers injected the diet soda with cultural cachet from beloved entertainers and public figures, a strategy employed from the brand’s earliest days even into contemporary promotions.

THE PACKAGING & LOGO HAVE GONE THROUGH MANY CHANGES

Diet Pepsi retro ad
Source: PepsiCo

As a mass market product, keeping Diet Pepsi’s packaging aesthetically current with shifting consumer tastes proved pivotal in maintaining strong brand perception over decades.

In 1994, Diet Pepsi made retail history as the first national beverage brand printing expiration dates directly on aluminum cans, dubbed “freshness dating.”

This innovation in product labeling afforded more transparency around shelf life for shoppers. Seeking even greater modernization later on, parent company PepsiCo twice overhauled Diet Pepsi’s entire visual branding first in 2008 and again the very next year, transforming its traditional logo into a new minimalist, lower-case stylized design.

These recurring major resets of coloring, typography, and graphics kept the Diet Pepsi brand continually feeling fresh rather than a faded relic of earlier decades.

Through such calculated revamps to outward-facing aesthetics every so often, the company ensured that ever-important packaging signaled the diet soda brand was up-to-date, not left behind by progress.

VARIANTS OF DIET PEPSI HAVE BEEN INTRODUCED OVER TIME

Pepsi Max ad
Source: PepsiCo

Seeking to broaden appeal amid intensifying diet soda competition, PepsiCo strategically expanded the Diet Pepsi brand franchise over decades through flavor-infused spinoff beverages.

Complementing the original flagship cola formulation, Diet Pepsi innovations like Wild Cherry, Vanilla, and Lime hit shelves at various points, offering sugar-free sippers a rotating portfolio of specialty tastes.

These frequent limited-edition flavor riffs provided novelty excitement to sustain public intrigue. Simultaneously, to capture calorie-mindful consumers desiring max taste without sugars, PepsiCo introduced complementary low-calorie colas like Pepsi Max as dietary alternatives to standard Diet Pepsi.

With interest in weight loss surging the 1980s forward, pushing such derivative brand extensions allowed PepsiCo to fully capitalize on burgeoning diet-minded demographics.

The resulting palette of closely-branded low and no calorie soda sub-brands effectively carved out shelf space, cementing Diet Pepsi as a power player in the expanding diet beverage sphere.

Collection

Next