Cartoon of a baker in a tall chef's hat sliding a tray of pastries into an oven marked Discontinued while a crowd reaches after them
Extra's lost flavors head into the Discontinued oven, as a cartoonist might draw it © History Oasis

15 DISCONTINUED EXTRA GUM FLAVORS THAT YOU’LL CHEW NO MORE


9 min read

Wrigley put dessert into Extra gum in October 2010, starting with Key Lime Pie, Strawberry Shortcake and Mint Chocolate Chip. Six years later Extra’s own flavor page had no dessert flavors left. These 15 discontinued Extra gum flavors run from the 2009 smoothie gums to Rockin’ Raspberry Lime in 2020, dated from Extra’s own website and the shoppers who spotted each one on shelves.

LIST OF DISCONTINUED EXTRA GUM FLAVORS

These are the 15 discontinued Extra flavors in the order they appeared. Wrigley and Mars never announced an end date for any of them, so “gone by” is the first time Extra’s own flavor page no longer listed the flavor.

FlavorOn shelvesGone by
Berry Smoothie2009December 2011
Mango Smoothie2009December 2011
Key Lime PieOctober 2010September 2013
Strawberry ShortcakeOctober 2010September 2013
Mint Chocolate ChipOctober 2010After 2022
Orange Creme PopSpring 2011September 2013
Apple PieFall 2011September 2013
Rainbow SherbetLate 2011February 2014
Root Beer FloatSummer 2012February 2014
Lemon SquareDecember 2012April 2015
Raspberry Vanilla CupcakeMay 2013April 2015
Peach CobblerFall 2013April 2015
Cinnamon RollMay 2014May 2016
Pumpkin SpiceAugust 2014Seasonal
Rockin’ Raspberry LimeNovember 2020Limited time

An earlier version of this list included Bananas Foster. It was never sold: it lost a 2011 fan vote (see Root Beer Float), so Mint Chocolate Chip takes its place.

BERRY SMOOTHIE AND MANGO SMOOTHIE

Extra Fruit Sensations Mango Smoothie gum ad reading Sip your gum
An Extra Mango Smoothie ad, 2009 / Wrigley

Gone by: December 2011

Berry Smoothie and Mango Smoothie were Extra’s smoothie gums, part of a fruit line called Extra Fruit Sensations. Wrigley planned to introduce them in March 2009, and trade writers called them new that August. By December 2011 Extra’s only Fruit Sensations flavors were Sweet Watermelon and Sweet Tropical, its flavor page shows.

KEY LIME PIE

Green Extra Dessert Delights Key Lime Pie gum pack on a lime green grid
An Extra Dessert Delights Key Lime Pie pack, 2010 / Wrigley

Gone by: September 2013

Key Lime Pie was one of the three flavors that launched Extra Dessert Delights in October 2010. “Sorry, Willy Wonka - Wrigley has a new dessert gum that won’t turn little girls into blueberries,” the San Francisco Chronicle wrote that week.

Extra called it “the best piece of Key Lime pie you’ve ever chewed.” One reviewer agreed, briefly. “Unfortunately, the flavor doesn’t last that long, leaving you with a tasteless gum in your mouth,” a St. Joseph, Missouri, newspaper columnist wrote in 2011. Key Lime Pie was still on Extra’s page in June 2012 and gone by September 2013.

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE

Extra Dessert Delights Strawberry Shortcake gum pack on a plate with whipped cream and a strawberry
An Extra Dessert Delights Strawberry Shortcake ad, 2010 / Wrigley

Gone by: September 2013

Strawberry Shortcake was another of the first three. “It’s as if strawberry shortcake were reincarnated as a stick of gum,” Extra’s flavor page said in 2011. Dessert Delights sold for.19 a 15-stick pack, and at 5 calories a stick, newspapers noted, they were pitched as a diet aid. Strawberry Shortcake was off Extra’s page by September 2013.

MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP

Green Extra Dessert Delights Mint Chocolate Chip 15-stick gum pack with a bowl of mint chocolate chip ice cream
An Extra Dessert Delights Mint Chocolate Chip pack / Wrigley

Gone by: After 2022

Mint Chocolate Chip was the third launch flavor and the last Dessert Delight standing. Extra described it as “gum that tastes like it belongs on a cone.” It dropped off Extra’s page by 2016, then came back in August 2017 “back by popular demand,” Mars said.

Extra’s own site still sold Dessert Delights Mint Chocolate Chip in November 2022. It is not among the 29 products on Extra’s site in November 2026.

ORANGE CREME POP

Orange Extra Dessert Delights Orange Creme Pop three-pack
An Extra Dessert Delights Orange Creme Pop three-pack, 2011 / Wrigley

Gone by: September 2013

Orange Creme Pop, on shelves by spring 2011, was a creamsicle in gum form. “No more waiting for the ice cream truck,” Extra’s page said. It was still listed on Extra’s mobile site in June 2013 and gone three months later.

APPLE PIE

Three Extra Dessert Delights Apple Pie gum packs on a dark red grid
Extra Dessert Delights Apple Pie packs, 2011 / Wrigley

Gone by: September 2013

Apple Pie followed Orange Creme Pop in the fall of 2011, Wrigley announced in June. “So much like apple pie you’ll ask for the recipe,” Extra promised. It left Extra’s page with Orange Creme Pop in 2013.

RAINBOW SHERBET

Pink Extra Dessert Delights Rainbow Sherbet gum pack with a scoop of sherbet
An Extra Dessert Delights Rainbow Sherbet pack / Wrigley

Gone by: February 2014

Rainbow Sherbet had two lives. It started as a Limited Edition, with “hints of orange, lemon and lime” (not raspberry), Extra said, and a reviewer called it “now-defunct” by June 2012. It was back on Extra’s page in September 2013, then gone again by February 2014.

ROOT BEER FLOAT

Box of Extra Dessert Delights Root Beer Float gum packs on a brown grid
A box of Extra Dessert Delights Root Beer Float, 2012 / Wrigley

Gone by: February 2014

Root Beer Float was chosen by fans. In Extra’s 2011 “Fan Flavorite Vote,” run on Facebook and phones, it took 662,817 votes, beating Lemon Square with 363,389 and Bananas Foster with 360,731, The Impulsive Buy reported.

It reached stores in summer 2012. “You can almost hear the fizz inside this stick,” Extra’s page said. It was gone by February 2014.

LEMON SQUARE

Yellow Extra Dessert Delights Lemon Square gum pack on a yellow grid
An Extra Dessert Delights Lemon Square pack, 2012 / Wrigley

Gone by: April 2015

Lemon Square lost the fan vote and launched anyway, by December 2012. The flavor was inspired by the winning dessert of a Quickfire Challenge on Bravo’s Top Chef Just Desserts, Wrigley said. Bananas Foster, the third choice, never went on sale. Lemon Square was off Extra’s page by April 2015.

RASPBERRY VANILLA CUPCAKE

Pink Extra Dessert Delights Raspberry Vanilla Cupcake three-pack on a pink grid
An Extra Dessert Delights Raspberry Vanilla Cupcake three-pack, 2013 / Wrigley

Gone by: April 2015

Raspberry Vanilla Cupcake was “the newest Extra Dessert Delights flavor” in 2013, “sweet and fruity with hints of vanilla,” Extra said. It reached shelves in May 2013 and was gone from Extra’s page two years later.

PEACH COBBLER

Extra Dessert Delights Peach Cobbler gum pack on a pink grid
An Extra Dessert Delights Peach Cobbler pack, 2013 / Wrigley

Gone by: April 2015

Peach Cobbler was Extra’s fall 2013 flavor. Wrigley could have gone with pumpkin pie, a shopper noted when it turned up in stores. Extra promised “a fresh-from-the-orchard taste,” its flavor page said in 2014. It lasted less than two years.

CINNAMON ROLL

Extra Dessert Delights Cinnamon Roll gum pack with an iced cinnamon roll
An Extra Dessert Delights Cinnamon Roll pack, 2014 / Wrigley

Gone by: May 2016

Cinnamon Roll, spotted at Target in May 2014, was the last new Dessert Delights flavor. Extra described “cinnamon sweetness with a touch of vanilla icing.” By May 2016 Extra’s flavor page listed no dessert flavors at all. Mars never said why the line ended.

PUMPKIN SPICE

Extra Seasonal Edition Pumpkin Spice gum pack on an orange grid
An Extra Seasonal Edition Pumpkin Spice pack, 2014 / Wrigley

Sold: Fall 2014, as a seasonal flavor

Extra Seasonal Edition Pumpkin Spice turned up at Kroger in August 2014. A reviewer tasted no squash at all, just “caramelized sugar, vanilla, cinnamon, and fruity clove,” in an October 2014 review.

ROCKIN’ RASPBERRY LIME

Limited Edition Extra Rockin' Raspberry Lime gum pack on a pink and green grid
An Extra Rockin' Raspberry Lime pack, 2020 / Mars Wrigley

Sold: From November 2020, for a limited time

Rockin’ Raspberry Lime was a limited-time Extra flavor Mars Wrigley unveiled in November 2020 in 15-stick slim packs, Snack Food & Wholesale Bakery reported. It was the first of a series of gum extensions aimed at convenience stores, the National Confectioners Association noted. It is not on Extra’s site today.

FAQ

Why was Extra Dessert Delights discontinued?

Wrigley and Mars never gave a reason for ending Extra Dessert Delights. The flavors left one by one between 2012 and 2016, and by May 2016 Extra’s flavor page listed no dessert flavors. Mint Chocolate Chip came back in 2017 and was still sold in 2022, but it is not on Extra’s site in November 2026.

Did they discontinue Extra Cinnamon gum?

Extra Cinnamon is not on Extra’s U.S. website in November 2026, but Mars never announced an end. Cinnamon came back to shelves in October 2016, Extra called it the newest member of its flavor family in 2017, and it was still listed on Extra’s flavor page in February 2021. Some sellers still list packs.

How many flavors of Extra gum are there?

Extra’s U.S. website lists 29 products in November 2026, covering about ten stick flavors, including Spearmint, Peppermint, Polar Ice, Smooth Mint, Winterfresh, Classic Bubble, Sweet Watermelon and Pink Lemonade, plus Extra Refreshers. None of the dessert flavors is among them.

When did Extra gum come out?

Wrigley introduced Extra in the United States in 1984 as its first sugar-free gum, and within five years it was the top-selling sugar-free gum brand, according to Extra’s own history. The dessert flavors came much later, starting with Extra Dessert Delights in October 2010.