Pull-Top Can


© History Oasis
"Much like the first Apple computer, the pull-top can was an invention born out of necessity, transforming a complicated process into a simple, intuitive gesture. It's a testament to the power of design as the fundamental soul of a human-made creation."

—Steve Jobs

The pull-top can, a seemingly ordinary facet of modern life, conceals a story fraught with technical challenges, environmental controversies, and unexpected cultural impacts.

It's a tale that unfolds not in the high-profile halls of Silicon Valley, but within the unassuming realm of everyday objects.

Through a historical lens, one realizes the journey of the pull-top can from its inception by an unsung inventor, Ermal Fraze, in 1959, to its ubiquitous presence in our picnic baskets, refrigerators, and recycling bins, is a testament to the subtle, uncelebrated innovations that shape our world.


pull-top can
© History Oasis

When we marvel at the innovations that define our modern world, we often overlook the seemingly mundane.

The pull-top can is one such entity—taken for granted and hidden in plain sight.

While the original can was invented in the early 19th century, it took until 1959, nearly a century and a half later, for the pull-top variation to be introduced to the world. Ermal Fraze, a Dayton, Ohio engineer and inventor, was the man behind this late bloom of innovation.

Technical Roadblocks

Fraze’s delayed invention was not due to a lack of creativity or ambition, but to the technical challenges inherent in the task at hand.

Creating a self-contained opening mechanism, one that was both reliable and easy to operate, was a feat that tested the limits of mid-century manufacturing capabilities.

It was not enough for the can to simply contain and preserve the beverage; it needed to be user-friendly, compact, and safe.

The Balancing Act of Design

Inventors and engineers are often required to walk a fine line, balancing utility and safety, cost-effectiveness and quality.

In the case of the pull-top can, this balance proved particularly elusive.

How could one design an opening mechanism that was secure enough to contain pressurized liquid, yet easy enough for the average consumer to open without tools or excessive force? How could the same piece of metal that sealed the drink also serve as the device to liberate it? And, above all, how could this be done cheaply enough to make mass production viable?


© History Oasis

The initial iteration of the pull-top can was more of a Pandora’s box than a consumer convenience.

The pop-top, despite its catchy, innocuous name, was a hazard in disguise. The sharp edges, an unintended consequence of the can's innovative design, often led to a painful surprise for unwary consumers.

Far from the benign beverage container we know today, the early pull-top can was akin to a mousetrap, waiting to snap.

An Environmental Nightmare

But the danger was not confined to the human realm.

Discarded pull-tops, discarded without thought, quickly became an environmental hazard.

Their small, seemingly insignificant presence belied a more sinister threat to wildlife. Animals, unable to distinguish between food and these tiny metallic intruders, fell victim to their silent onslaught.

Tires, too, bore the brunt of these cast-off artifacts of human convenience, their sharp edges capable of inflicting serious damage.


portrait of pull-top inventor, Ermal Fraze
© History Oasis

It was on an afternoon much like any other that Ermal Fraze stumbled upon an idea that would change the beverage industry forever.

At a simple picnic, of all places, the seeds of innovation were sown.

Faced with the decidedly low-tech problem of a can and no opener, Fraze was struck with a moment of insight that would resonate far beyond that quiet park.

Necessity, the Unconventional Mother of Invention

His solution to the missing can opener was an exercise in pragmatic improvisation: he pried his drink open with a car bumper.

As the carbonated contents fizzed and frothed, a realization bubbled to the surface.

There had to be an easier way—a design that eliminated the need for external tools and turned the can into a self-contained vessel of refreshment.

And thus, from a moment of irritation arose an invention that would transform a global industry.

An idea sparked by a day out in the sun, the lack of a can opener, and a stubborn refusal to remain thirsty.


Jimmy Buffet singing about the Pull-top can
© History Oasis

It may seem mundane, but this everyday object has etched its mark on the canvas of pop culture, popping up in places one might least expect.

The Pull-Tab in Song

Take, for instance, the world of music. Jimmy Buffett, renowned for his laid-back tunes that encapsulate the carefree beachside lifestyle, immortalized the pull-tab can in his hit song, "Margaritaville."

With lyrics lamenting stepping on a 'pop top', Buffett struck a chord with listeners around the world.

He turned this commonplace object into a metaphorical pitfall on the path to paradise—a simple, yet resonant image.


landfill full of pull-tops
© History Oasis

In the rush to embrace the convenience of the pull-tab can, society overlooked a significant fallout - the environmental impact of discarded tabs.

The very design that made the pull-tab can so convenient also made it a notable contributor to litter. T

he tabs, once pulled, were often tossed away without thought, creating a widespread problem of pollution. This design flaw would soon prove to be a rallying cry for environmental activists.

A Public Wake-Up Call

The late 1960s and early 1970s saw the rise of environmental consciousness, a time when the public began to realize the collective impact of their individual actions.

The scattered pull-tabs, a visual reminder of casual disregard for the environment, became symbolic of this awakening.

Grassroots campaigns began to spring up, advocating for a change in the design of the pull-tab can—a change that would eliminate the detached tabs that so often ended up tarnishing nature's beauty.

A Can's Evolution

These campaigns marked the beginning of a shift in mindset, where the consumers' demand for convenience was balanced against the need for environmental stewardship.

It was a pivotal moment that would lead to the invention of the "stay-on-tab" in the mid-1970s—a design tweak that would mitigate the environmental impact while preserving the can's ease of use.


trash on the beach
© History Oasis

In the annals of legislative history, it's rare for an object as commonplace as a can to take center stage.

However, in 1972, Oregon became the unlikely battleground for a clash between convenience and environmental conservation. The state, witnessing the environmental fallout of discarded pull-tabs, took a bold stance and banned the ubiquitous pull-top can.

From the Pacific Northwest to the National Stage

This landmark law sent shockwaves through the beverage industry and served as a rallying cry for environmentalists.

Oregon's ban was more than just a local initiative—it was a bellwether, signaling a shift in public sentiment and prompting other states to consider similar legislation.

The humble pull-top can, once a symbol of modern convenience, was now a controversial artifact, its very existence under scrutiny.

The Birth of the Stay-On-Tab

The ban posed an existential challenge to the beverage industry—adapt or become obsolete.

The result was a rapid redesign of the pull-top can, a move driven by necessity rather than innovation.

The stay-on-tab was born out of this pressure, an example of how external forces can spur industry evolution.


© History Oasis

In the chaotic and brutal theater of the Vietnam War, the pull-tab found an unexpected and poignant role.

Far from the picnics and beach parties where it was a symbol of leisure and refreshment, the pull-tab took on a much darker significance amidst the violence and devastation of war.

The soldiers began to wear these pieces of aluminum on their dog tags, transforming them into harrowing keepsakes.

A Grim Scorecard

In the hands of the soldiers, the pull-tab was no longer just a piece of a beverage can.

It became a chilling token, each one representing a life taken in the fog of war.

Soldiers would add these to their dog tags as a grim tally, an ever-present reminder of the brutal reality of their existence. A simple piece of metal was thus imbued with profound meaning, a stark symbol of the human cost of conflict.


© History Oasis

Coca-Cola, a titan in the beverage industry, is no stranger to innovation. Yet, when it came to the pull-top can, the company proved surprisingly reticent.

While many other businesses were quick to embrace the convenience of the pull-tab, Coca-Cola held back, choosing a path of caution over immediate consumer convenience.

Safety Before Speed

This resistance was not rooted in stubbornness but driven by a deep concern for consumer safety and the preservation of the brand's image.

The early pull-top designs, as we've explored, were riddled with issues—sharp edges that could cut unwary fingers, loose tabs posing environmental hazards, and the potential for consumers to accidentally ingest the tabs.

Coca-Cola, with its global reputation, was keenly aware that the adoption of an imperfect design could damage its image and potentially harm its loyal customer base.

The Late Adoption

It was not until 1967, a good number of years after the introduction of pull-tabs, that Coca-Cola finally incorporated the feature into its cans.

This decision was a calculated one, showcasing the company's commitment to prioritizing safety and brand integrity over the quick adoption of new, albeit flawed, technology.


pull-top cans
© History Oasis

Every compelling historical narrative has its fringe elements, and the story of the pull-tab can is no exception.

Amidst the tales of technological innovation and environmental impact, a subplot of intrigue and conspiracy has woven itself into the fabric of this everyday object's history.

The Covert Aluminum Agenda

A small yet persistent cadre of conspiracy theorists posit that the pull-tab can was not simply the brainchild of an inventive engineer but a tool of secret government agencies.

They claim the real goal was to stimulate the production of aluminum, a key industrial material, as part of a wider geopolitical strategy.

This theory paints the humble pull-tab can as a pawn in a high-stakes game of global dominance.